peconic bay yacht club

Peconic Bay Yacht Club

64300 Main Road, Southold, NY

About this vendor

Pricing details, amenities + details.

• Civil Union
• Commitment Ceremony
• Interfaith Ceremony
• Non-Religious Ceremony
• Religious Ceremony
• Second Wedding
• Country Club
• Bar & Drinks
• Food & Catering
• Service Staff

• Top reviews
• Newest first
• Oldest first
• Highest rated
• Lowest rated

Meet the team

Wedding vendors in Southold

• 301 or more
• Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure.
• Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place.
• Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go.
• For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.
• Wedding Vendors /
• Wedding Venues /
• New York Wedding Venues /
• Southold Wedding Venues /

Peconic Bay Yacht Club Reviews

Peconic bay yacht club.

• Quality of service 5 out of 5 rating 5.0
• Average response time 5 out of 5 rating 5.0
• Professionalism 5 out of 5 rating 5.0
• Value 5 out of 5 rating 5.0
• Flexibility 5 out of 5 rating 5.0

• Quality of service 5.0 out of 5 rating 5.0
• Average response time 5.0 out of 5 rating 5.0
• Professionalism 5.0 out of 5 rating 5.0
• Value 5.0 out of 5 rating 5.0
• Flexibility 5.0 out of 5 rating 5.0

Top choice for the best day of your life!

Our wedding at Peconic was PERFECT!!

PBYC is a dream come true!!

Are you interested?

Amazing! 5-stars All Around!

October wedding at Peconic Bay Yacht Club

Beyond amazing!!!

Extraordinary Night at PBYC!

PBYC is a dream!

A day/night to remember forever!!

Wedding 10/29/22

Outstanding in every way

A Perfect Day!

Father of the Bride

Perfect Day at a Perfect Venue

PBYC is the best decision you will make!

Perfect Wedding Venue!

What dreams are made of!

Best wedding venue on Long Island!

Exceeded our very high expectations!

Wedding ceremony and reception

Flawless, elevated wedding experience

Would choose PBYC again, and again, and again

A perfect location to get married1

Peconic Bay Yacht Club

Location & Hours

Suggest an edit

64300 Main Rd

Southold, NY 11971

You Might Also Consider

Events by Peter Ambrose

6.8 miles away from Peconic Bay Yacht Club

the best food and most experienced catering team on Eastern Long Island since 1991. read more

in Caterers

Tailored Events

Baby Shower Balloon Arch Wonderful Photo Op read more

in Party Supplies, Party & Event Planning

Sperry Tents Hamptons

10.5 miles away from Peconic Bay Yacht Club

Sperry Tents Hamptons is an award-winning tent rental company and outdoor event specialist locatedon Long Island. We are the exclusive provider of Sperry Tents – the industry’s most elegant and sought-after rental tent. read more

in Party Equipment Rentals, Party & Event Planning

People also searched for

Wedding Venues

Late Night Eats

Outdoor Bar

Catering Services

Recommended Reviews

• 1 star rating Not good
• 2 star rating Could’ve been better
• 3 star rating OK
• 4 star rating Good
• 5 star rating Great

Select your rating

Overall rating

You know it was an amazing time if it's taken about two months for us to recover from all the dancing and incredible amount of fun we had at our wedding! To say the entire PBYC team (especially looking at you, John) made our wedding a day one that we couldn't have dreamt of and a day and experience we'll never forget is a massive understatement. They might be some of the finest professionals I've ever had the pleasure of working with and am SO grateful I got to for our wedding day. They treated us like we were the only couple they had booked for the entire year -- no request or question was too big, small, or silly. On top of that, they made everything feel fun and easy, even though wedding planning can feel like one of the most stressful things ever at points. I am eternally grateful for having gotten to feel like one of the most special people on earth because of John and his team at PBYC. If it weren't for their kindness, insane amount of effort and attention to detail, willingness to go above and beyond, I know our wedding wouldn't have been as amazing. John has such a gift in doing what he does for a living. If you were on the fence in considering PBYC, let me tell you this -- you should consider this your sign to do it NOW. You will not find a better team, a more beautiful location, and holy SMOKES... no better food, anywhere else. Thank you John and the entire team at PBYC for everything you did to make our wedding a weekend and experience one we'll never forget and our guests will never stop talking about. TEAM PBYC FOREVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Attended a wedding there last night, it was outstanding! The grounds were impeccable and the building offered many wonderful options. Food was very good. But the one element that clearly stood out was the service; bartenders and servers were outstanding! Clearly the management has everyone on the same page. Well done!

To say that our wedding at the PBYC was the wedding of our dreams is an understatement...words cannot begin to describe how exceptional the entire experience was! From the outset, we knew we had made the right decision when picking our venue. Working with John over the last year was an absolute pleasure. His kindness, support, experience, and sense of humor made the entire process easy. Despite the fact that the last year and a half has been beyond difficult dealing with COVID, health restrictions, social distancing and countless unknowns, John was always there with a smile, a joke, and reassurances for us. Any questions we had were addressed immediately. By the time our wedding came around we were beyond confident that everything was going to run smoothly. And then came our wedding day. It was truly beautiful and while the weather certainly played a role in that, the Yacht Club itself was the perfect setting. Everything looked beautiful! John and the staff at the PBYC work hard to make the place an absolutely stunning venue, from the lawn overlooking the bay where we had our ceremony, to the upstairs patio where our guests enjoyed the best cocktail hour imaginable, to the main dining room with it's picture perfect views of the marina and greater bay beyond. Pictures are just starting to roll in and they are stunning! We also have to note how amazing the entire staff working that day were. Our guests are still remarking on how fabulous the service was. No one wanted for anything. We were fortunate enough to have Hillary work with us as our bridal attendant that day; she was phenomenal! She was always there at our side whenever we needed a drink, a bite to eat, or just a reminder to take some time for ourselves if we needed to. Thanks to her, John, and everyone else, we were able to relax, enjoy our family and friends, and have the best time ever. We cannot begin to thank John and everyone at the PBYC for making our special day an amazing one with memories that we will treasure for years to come!

Stop looking! Have. Your. Wedding. HERE! The well-manicured grass area overlooking the water, wedding party preparation areas, reception room and the upstairs bar area with HUGE balcony and very unique lantern room made for a remarkable and perfect setting for our special day! It could have not been more perfect. It is made easy given that you have the venue to yourself all day from 9 am until 1am. The staff and coordinators are extremely attentive and professional. They could not have been sweeter or more accommodating. They made our day very easy and stress free. We looked at several other venues and this one blew them all away. No detail was ignored. Oh, and we are still hearing how amazing the food was. Such an amazing place!

The Peconic Bay Yacht Club was everything we could have wished for and more! On top of how absolutely stunning the views are, the inside of the venue is impeccably designed and absolutely gorgeous. In addition to how wonderful PBYC is, they work exclusively with Robbins Wolfe catering - the food at our wedding was outstanding - we are still getting compliments! Most importantly, John and his staff went above and beyond in every single way possible when it came to planning our big day. While planning, we were told by so many people not to get too caught up in tiny details because inevitably something small can go wrong - I can honestly say that, not only did nothing go wrong, but everything was truly perfect - beyond what I could have even hoped for. John thought of every single detail imaginable, responded to every call/email immediately, and was there for us every step of the way. I didn't have a wedding planner or a day of planner, and I know that wouldn't have been remotely possible without John. My bridal attendant, Emily, was honestly my saving grace and I could not have imagined this day without her. John and Emily both thought of things that didn't even cross my mind - they are truly the absolute best!! I wouldn't have changed one single thing about our wedding and cannot recommend the Peconic Bay Yacht Club place more!

3 other reviews that are not currently recommended

Tanglewood Catering

Stephanie F. said "Four weeks before our wedding was supposed to happen in a catering hall we were forced to cancel or postpone to 2021 and let me tell you picking Taglewood Catering was the best decision we ever could have made! Nick, the boss/face…" read more

Comfort Inn Guilford Near I-95

Tania M. said "My husband and I stayed here one night on our way to Boston because they have a Tesla charger. We didn't expect much and were pleasantly surprised with the hotel and the town. The room was clean and comfortable. There were a few…" read more

Collections Including Peconic Bay Yacht Club

By Summer M.

People Also Viewed

Atlantis Banquets & Events

The Vineyards at Aquebogue

Christopher Michael Catering

360 East at Montauk Downs

East End Entertainment

Trumpets At The Gate

Giorgio’s Baiting Hollow

Chef Christopher Hensel

Catering by A Small Affair

Browse Nearby

Restaurants

Things to Do

Thrift Stores

Other Venues & Event Spaces Nearby

Find more Venues & Event Spaces near Peconic Bay Yacht Club

People found Peconic Bay Yacht Club by searching for…

Wedding Venues Southold

Related Cost Guides

Boat Charters

Golf Cart Rentals

Karaoke Rental

Party & Event Planning

Photo Booth Rentals

Valet Services

Venues and Event Spaces

You are using an outdated browser. Please upgrade your browser or activate Google Chrome Frame to improve your experience.

• Party Venues

Peconic Bay Yacht Club

• Phone 631-407-5200
• www.culinartcateringcollection.com
• Capacity: 260 people

About Peconic Bay Yacht Club

• Online Menu
• Write A Recommendation

Event Spaces

See Details

Overlooking the marina, The Ballroom is ideal for your larger parties and designed for dinner and dancing in the traditional style.

Supported Layouts and Capacities

Situated on the second floor of the Club, The Gallery & Terrace offers panoramic water views. This space is perfect for cocktail receptions, indoor ceremonies, or intimate dinners and dancing.

Located on the main floor, The Lounge is a stately setting to welcome guest or enjoy a quiet moment beside a roaring fire and tranquil views.

Let the stunning views be your backdrop as you exchange your vows under the arbor or host your tented reception on The Point at the Peconic Bay Yacht Club.

The Tasting Room offers access to the Wine Cellar, Bar Room and Chef’s Table for your most intimate dinners or events. Enjoy wine tasting with your guests in the Cellar and bespoke entertaining in the Bar Room followed by fireside dining at the Robbins Wolfe Chef’s Table.

• Boat/Yacht, Banquet/Event Hall, Country Club
• ADA/ACA Accessible
• Fully Equipped Kitchen
• On-Site Catering Service
• Outdoor Function Area
• Outside Catering Allowed
• Wireless Internet/Wi-Fi
• Max Number of People for an Event: 260

• Best of the North Fork
• Classifieds
• Read Digital Edition
• Write the Editor

Browse By Location .st123123{fill:none;stroke:#000000;stroke-width:10;stroke-miterlimit:10;}

• Baiting Hollow
• East Marion
• Long Island
• New Suffolk
• Off the Fork
• Shelter Island
• Wading River

Sign up for our Newsletter

Peconic bay yacht club will host some of the north fork’s grandest weddings, stay up to date.

Get the latest North Fork stories, recommendations, and upcoming events right to your inbox with our daily newsletter.

After standing vacant and unused for years, the former Mill Creek Inn in Southold will once again host some of the North Fork’s most elegant weddings and stylish shindigs.

Peconic Bay Yacht Club, a 10,000-square-foot building overlooking Peconic Bay, with a marina and manicured grounds, hosted its first wedding last weekend and its owners are ready to start booking more events.

Despite the name, don’t expect a social club or restaurant at the Main Road property, located just west of the Greenport border.

“It’s only a yacht club by name,” said co-owner John Ingrilli. “It’s a catering hall. People can decide how to utilize the property based on their event.”

Should a guest at Peconic Bay Yacht Club forget that the affair they are attending is located on the North Fork, a parking lot covered in crushed clam shells with hydrangea-lined walkways and a large anchor leaning against the dock house will remind them. The cedar-shingle siding and gables give the building the feel of a New England seaside estate and an arbor near the shore offers an ideal spot for a couple to say “I do.”

Inside, the ground floor features a comfortable lounge, a full-service kitchen, handicapped-accessible bathrooms and a ballroom with views of the bay. The second floor offers a bridal suite, another party area ripe for a cocktail hour, additional bathrooms and an outdoor deck with the bay as its backdrop.

The floors are made of wide-plank oak and the walls sport horizontal white planks. The decor is done in light and dark blue hues and the textured wallpaper, curated objects and wall hangings give the space a nautical feel.

“[The owners] wanted an Old-World feel, but something fresh,” said designer Kate Burger, whose father, Eugene Burger of Burger Construction in Cutchogue, is one of the owners. “We wanted it to have an updated feel, but feel like it’s always been here.”

Outside the building an 80-foot handicapped-accessible ramp leads to the 50-slip marina. The eco-friendly bulkheading is buffered by Cape American beach grass and wetland grass, which are fed by the bay at high tide.

“During the day at high tide it looks like a fish tank,” Mr. Ingrilli said. “Because of our affinity for the water we wanted to make it as green and eco-friendly as possible.”

The original inn, which stood in disrepair years after its heyday as a seaside nightspot and wedding hall, was torn down in 2005 and this new building rose in its footprint.

But since 2007, the building — originally constructed by Richard Principi of Principi Properties, who received a stop-work order from Southold Town — has stood vacant and unused.

Mill Creek Partners LLC, led by Mr. Burger, purchased the property in 2011 for $2.47 million.

“We drove by here and Eugene was living out here full time. The place was abandoned but it had potential,” said Mr. Ingrilli, a part-time Cutchogue resident. “We decided to look into acquiring it.”

It’s a project four years in the making for the owners, who spent more than half that time navigating the permit process. The partners declined to say how much it cost to complete the project.

“It was a lot of hard work, so it feels great [that it is finished],” Mr. Burger said.

That work culminated when Mr. Ingrilli’s daughter Alyssa became the first bride to celebrate her wedding on the property last Saturday.

The reception was held under a Sperry tent, with Peconic Bay breezes wafting through to cool off the guests, and was catered by Elegant Affairs.

“It was wonderful, it really was,” Mr. Ingrilli said.

The space can accommodate parties of up to a few hundred people, he added. The owners have not yet decided whether they will use an exclusive caterer or allow customers to select a food provider from an approved list. They are also unsure if they will provide seating and tables.

For information, call 631-407-5200 or email [email protected] . A website has not yet been created.

Mr. Ingrilli noted that completion of the project, along with the 2013 opening of the renovated Southold Fish Market across Main Road — has breathed new life into the stretch of land between Peconic Bay and Hashamomuck Pond.

“We thought it would improve the whole location,” he said. “This particular area is coming a lot further in becoming aesthetically pleasing. It gives it a real North Fork feel.”

[email protected]

Vera Chinese has been the editor of northforker.com and northforker magazines since May 2014. Prior to that she spent two and a half years as a staff reporter for the New York Daily News. She joined the Riverhead News-Review as a staff writer in January 2010 and was named Associate Web Editor nine months later. She previously worked for the Southampton Press Western Edition and was named the third place 2008 Rookie Reporter of the Year by the New York Press Association. She graduated from Wagner College in 2006 where she received a bachelor's degree in English. She earned a master's degree in English education from New York University in 2007. She is a 2002 graduate of Eastport High School and has lived on the East End for more than 20 years.

Related Content

Grammy nominee Brady Rymer looks back on more than four decades of rockin’

Brady Rymer, a Southold resident with three Grammy nominations under his belt for children’s...

North Fork Open Houses: 8 listings for the weekend of April 12

Living on the North Fork, with its picturesque villages, varied restaurants, historic farms and...

North Fork Dream Home: Pretty from porch to pool in Southold

If you believe home is where the farm is, then you’ll want to take...

• Wedding Vendors
• Best Of Vendors
• Vendor Info Request
• Diamond Promotions
• Bridal Shows
• Wedding Forum
• Newlywed Forum
• Forum Mail [FM]
• Venue Guide
• Real Weddings
• Destination Weddings
• Engagements
• Engagement Rings
• Marriage License
• Wedding Songs
• Ask LIWeddings
• Wedding Tips
• LIWedding Blogs
• Vendor Blogs
• Enter The Contest
• Meet Our Winners

Peconic Bay Yacht Club

My wife and I got married in October at the Peconic Bay Yacht Club and the wedding was nothing short of perfect. John is the best in the business and he and his staff were incredible throughout the process and made everything from the first stages of planning to the wedding and everything in between so fun and stress-free. We have gotten so many compliments and rave reviews from friends and family about the venue. We had so much fun, the food was incredible, the setup with bars and staff was perfect, and everything else about the day was just so special. We could not imagine the best day of our lives happening anywhere else.

Went here for a family friend's wedding and was blown away by how polished this place was. Staff was excellent and food was amazing.

From the moment we met John and saw the beautiful venue we knew this was the one. After an exhaustive search of venues in Manhattan, Brooklyn, the North Fork, the Hamptons and the Hudson Valley we were starting to think the venue we were envisioning did not exist. PBYC met all of our requirements and more. John was super friendly, extremely helpful and always responsive. (He would answer our many late night emails within minutes) John is the gold standard for what every venue manger should be. After our wedding we had so many people reach out to us to tell us how amazing he was. We had no major hiccups thanks to John’s attention to detail, organization and preparation. Also, the venue is beyond stunning, it is absolutely breathtaking. From the gorgeous outdoor area on the water to the perfectly decorated interior (each area has its own personality) you will fall in love with the grounds. Throughout the day we utilized all of their spaces with an outdoor ceremony, cocktail hour on the balcony, dinner in the dining room, dancing on the 2nd floor and an after party in the Cellar Bar. Not only is PBYC a beautiful venue, but their partnership with Robbins Wolfe catering elevates the experience. The food was unique and absolutely delicious. We are still receiving messages from our guests that they are craving the burrata! The quality of the wine and spirits is above and beyond any other venue (and trust me, we have been to a lot of weddings!) We strongly recommend booking your big day at Peconic Bay Yacht Club. After touring the venue and meeting John you will know you ended up at the right place!

My husband and I got married at Peconic Bay Yacht Club back in November. When we first got engaged, we looked at so many venues (a dozen to be exact), and nothing even came close to PBYC. The venue is stunning- every detail in the design is flawless. From our first email interaction, to our first venue tour and throughout the entire year long planning process- John, the General Manager was incredible. Absolutely incredible. His knowledge, attention to detail, and response time are unlike any other person I have had the pleasure of working with. John had an answer for everything, and often would respond within minutes of receiving my email. From our first interaction, John made us feel like he actually wanted our wedding there. A lot of the venues we saw, it was like they were doing us a favor by giving us a tour- not with John. Nothing was ever rushed, and he took the best care of us. John was everything you can wish for (and then some) in a venue General Manager The day of our wedding was flawless. John was instrumental in this. The food was incredible, not your typical catered wedding food. Guests are still raving about the food and the breath taking views three months later, thanks to Robbins Wolfe and their exquisite menu. Guests are also still talking about the caliber of service. There was no waiting in line for the bar or the bathroom. Each person at the table received their entree at the same exact time, it was next level service. I could not recommend PBYC more, it was an unbelievable experience working with John and team, especially in what can often be a stressful planning process. Book your wedding there, and know you are in good hands. Wish we could relive the day again!

My fiancé and I are getting married at the Peconic Bay Yacht Club in September 2018. This venue is amazing and beautiful both inside and out. It’s beautifully designed and furnished with spectacular views of the Peconic Bay. We recently had our food tasting and as expected the food was fantastic. The general manager John O from Robbins Wolfe, the caterer at the PBYC, was not only very helpful and kind but he has been an absolute pleasure to work with. His attention to detail, knowledge and response time have been exceptional. Most importantly he makes us feel like this is his only wedding and we are his personal friends. We know with John, we are in great hands! My fiancé and I have no doubt that our wedding is going to be everything we wanted and more. We are so excited to celebrate at the PBYC and cannnot wait until September!

Pristine, picturesque and purely incredible.

• About Kelly
• Information & Investment
• Testimonials

Peconic Bay Wedding - The North Fork - Taryn & Marc

Hamptons , new york , wedding.

Your Narrative blog will appear here, click preview to see it live. For any issues click here

Taryn and Marc had a beautiful fall Peconic Bay wedding at Peconic Bay Yacht Club .  The club is located in one of my favorite little towns on the North Fork of Long Island, surrounded by beaches and wineries.   I’ve been lucky enough to spend some vacation time out in the North Fork (often referred to as the Hampton’s laid-back neighbor) and I have quickly come to love it’s quirky charms!

Taryn and Marc began their Peconic Bay wedding with the bride getting ready upstairs and the groom in the basement bar.  Taryn chose a lacy Rosa Clará gown, with natural makeup by Cherise Lorén Beauty and beachy waves by Hairstories .  The couple opted not to do a first look, but we still took some time before the ceremony to take photos with their wedding parties separately, something I highly recommend to save time later in the day.

After their ceremony at Our lady of Good Counsel in Mattituck , we returned to Peconic Bay Yacht Club.  You can tell immediately in all of Taryn and Marc’s photos that it was a windy day on the water, but these two embraced it and their windswept portraits became some of my favorite photos to date!  We got lucky with the most gorgeous evening light followed by a beautiful sunset over the bay.  I loved photographing these two – their affection for each other radiates immediately (plus they weren’t afraid to do a little rock scrambling to get the shot!).  

After braving the chilly November wind, we all rushed back inside for the reception.  The dinner space was perfectly decorated by The Flower Petaler and guests were gifted local North Fork honey to take home.  It was such a fun, lighthearted day, which ended perfectly with a great dance party lead by Crossing Midnight Entertainment Band . Congrats T&M!

Venue – Peconic Bay Yacht Club

Church – Our lady of Good Counsel, Mattituck

Bride’s Gown – Rosa Clará

Hair – Hairstories

Makeup – Cherise Lorén Beauty

Florist – The Flower Petaler

Band – Crossing Midnight Entertainment Band

Check out this other gorgeous Peconic Bay Wedding in my portfolio !

South Street Seaport Engagement - Courtney & Shane

The mansion at natirar wedding - new jersey -amanda & rj, follow along on instagram.

© 2020 KELLYKOLLAR.COM

The Bridal Suite

Return to main gallery